A São Paulo court has barred Meta from using Brazilian news content to train Meta AI without authorization — and three days later, the company suspended indefinitely the change to its Commercial Terms that would have allowed the collection. The rule was due to take effect on November 20.
What the injunction orders
The injunction was granted on Tuesday, November 3, by judge Guilherme Madeira Dezem of the 44th Civil Court of São Paulo's Central Civil Forum, in a lawsuit filed by the National Newspaper Association (ANJ), the Brazilian Association of Radio and Television Broadcasters (ABERT) and the National Association of Magazine Editors (ANER). The case number is 4214874-21.2026.8.26.0100.
The ruling suspends, until the case is finally decided, the final part of Clause 1 of Meta's Commercial Terms and bars the company from using automated programs — robots, crawlers and scrapers — to collect content from the member outlets' websites and use it to develop, train or fine-tune Meta AI. Meta must also keep those outlets' accounts, pages and tools fully working, with no blocks, restrictions or punishment for refusing the new terms. Non-compliance carries a fine of R$ 1 million per day, capped at R$ 100 million.
What was at stake
The new Commercial Terms apply to anyone using Facebook, Instagram, WhatsApp or Threads for business purposes. Under the new version, Meta could send automated programs to these companies' websites to access, copy, store and analyse articles, photographs, videos and other content — including copyrighted works and material published outside the company's platforms. Continuing to use the networks after the effective date would count as acceptance. The original effective date was October 30 and had already been postponed to November 20. According to the ANJ, the ruling found signs of copyright infringement and contractual abuse.
Three days later, Meta backed down
On Friday, November 6, Meta suspended the update to the Commercial Terms indefinitely: the new rules will not take effect on November 20, and there is no new date. The notice was published in Meta's Business Help Center and at the top of the Commercial Terms page. With the pause, the current terms, in force since March 6, 2024, remain in effect. The company said it remains in dialogue with stakeholders and will share new information as soon as possible.
On the injunction itself, Meta told Poder360 that it will not comment on the decision. The company has five days to challenge the precautionary request, and the three associations have 30 business days to file the main claim.
A Brazilian precedent
According to the ANJ, the injunction is the first court decision known in the world granted to a coalition of media associations against Meta's new rules. On October 28, a court in Norway had already temporarily suspended the same rules, following a lawsuit by ten media groups in the country. For ANJ's chief executive, Marcelo Rech, “the injunction is a very positive sign that there are limits to the abuse of economic power by a large digital platform”.
What is still open
The injunction is provisional: it stands until the final judgment, and the merits have yet to be decided. The suspension also applies only to outlets affiliated with ANJ, ABERT and ANER — outside that group, the old terms apply. And there is a nuance: the old terms also contain a collection clause, which allows Meta to access and analyse the content of advertisers' domains for advertising, research and training. In other words, the dispute is far from over: what the court has blocked, for now, is the new rule that would have made collecting content for Meta AI a condition for keeping an account.
Image: logo of Meta Platforms, Inc., via Wikimedia Commons. Meta is a registered trademark of Meta Platforms, Inc.
Also on Geekiki: Meta Takes: prediction app with virtual currency and AI-generated questions
Sources
- ANJ — Justiça proíbe Meta de usar conteúdo jornalístico sem autorização após ação de ANJ, ABERT e ANER
- Antihype — Justiça proíbe Meta de usar conteúdo jornalístico sem aval
- VOH — Justiça de SP suspende cláusula da Meta que exigia conteúdo de veículos para treinar a Meta AI
- Antihype — Meta adia regra sobre conteúdo jornalístico e IA
- Isaque Victor — A Meta suspendeu os termos que liam o seu site
Transparency note: this article was produced with the help of artificial intelligence, based on public posts and sources on the internet, and reviewed editorially. Please consult the original sources to confirm the information.
By Muse