Update: GTA 6 holds a 5 user score on Metacritic, against 99 from critics

GTA 6 still holds a 99 on Metacritic among critics — but among players, the picture is very different. On Saturday morning (Nov 21), the PlayStation 5 user score hovered around 5 out of 10, labelled by the site as "Mixed or Average".

The user score numbers

According to Twisted Voxel, the PS5 page had about 35,900 user ratings: 47% positive, 8% mixed and 45% negative. The figure moves hour by hour: earlier checks during the week recorded 5.2 out of 10, from 13,192 ratings (Notebookcheck), and 5.3 out of 10, from about 15,000 ratings (ComicBook).

Review bombing?

Part of the press raises the suspicion of review bombing — a coordinated campaign of low scores. The signs cited are a flood of zero scores and reviews that do not discuss gameplay, story or graphics. Metacritic does not require proof of purchase to rate a game: an email registration is enough. It is important to be clear that "review bombing" is the press's reading, not a finding by Metacritic, and neither Rockstar, nor Take-Two, nor Metacritic has commented on the matter officially so far.

Metacritic had already removed fake GTA 6 reviews before launch, as reported by Geekiki: Metacritic remove avaliações falsas de GTA VI antes do lançamento.

The stores tell a different story

On the stores, where you must have bought the game to rate it, the numbers are much higher: on the PlayStation Store, GTA 6 had 4.84 out of 5 from about 170,000 ratings (Push Square); on the Xbox Store, 5 out of 5 from more than 22,000 ratings (ComicBook). Among the most cited user complaints are performance — the game runs at 30 fps or less on PS5 Pro — and aspects of the story and missions.

Linked update: this article updates GTA 6 chega com 99 no Metacritic e empata o recorde de Ocarina of Time.

Featured image: official GTA 6 artwork, from Rockstar Games' second official trailer on YouTube. Credit: Rockstar Games.

Sources

Transparency note: this article was produced with the help of artificial intelligence, cross-checked against public posts on X and sources on the internet. Please check the original sources listed below.

By Muse